Add Us As A Trusted Google Source 
Bella Vida Cafe
Cape May, New Jersey is one of the most charming seaside destinations on the East Coast, and the good news for travelers with dietary restrictions is that its restaurant scene has kept pace with its reputation for hospitality. Whether you are gluten-free, vegetarian, or vegan, dining well in Cape May is entirely doable and genuinely delightful as long as you come prepared. The best strategy is to call ahead or check restaurant websites before you go, since menus change seasonally and chefs are usually happy to accommodate when given notice. Look for restaurants that explicitly mark dietary options on their menus, as this signals a kitchen that takes the matter seriously. And if you are staying at the Wilbraham Mansion, you are already off to a great start. The inn can accommodate most diets with advance notice for the breakfast that is included with every room.
Key Takeaways:
- Cape May has a strong and growing selection of restaurants that cater to gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan diners across a range of price points and cuisines.
- Several restaurants, including Lucky Bones Backwater Grille, Taco Caballito, Oyster Bay, and Bella Vida Cafe, clearly mark dietary options on their menus or maintain dedicated gluten-free menus, making ordering straightforward.
- Iccara Italian Bistro and Taco Caballito stand out as particularly versatile, accommodating gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan diners all under one roof.
- Aloha Smoothie Company, Good Earth Organic Eatery, and Louisa’s are go-to destinations for plant-based eaters looking for a full, satisfying meal rather than a side salad.
- The Washington Inn and Wine Bar and The Cricket Club represent Cape May’s more upscale dining options, both of which thoughtfully incorporate gluten-free dishes into their menus.
- Calling ahead or checking restaurant websites is always recommended, especially for groups with multiple or complex dietary needs.
Want to share this infographic?
Gluten-Free Friendly Restaurants in Cape May
For gluten-free diners, Cape May offers a surprisingly rich landscape.
- Lucky Bones Backwater Grille, opened by the Craig family in 2006, has become a local institution for good reason. Their gluten-free menu is so extensive it has its own dedicated page on their website, covering everything from the house-smoked BBQ to their famous mussels and pasta. It is the kind of place where gluten-free guests do not feel like an afterthought.
- Iccara Italian Bistro, helmed by Executive Chef and Owner Vincenzo Sanzone, brings the flavors of Southern Sicily to the heart of Cape May with gluten-free options across every section of the menu. This includes most of their pastas, which is no small feat for an Italian restaurant.
- Taco Caballito Tequileria, located steps from the beach, offers a dedicated gluten-free menu featuring elevated Mexican dishes made with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.
- The Washington Inn and Wine Bar, a Cape May institution since 1978, is worth a visit for its poached shrimp appetizer, short rib, and porcini mushroom risotto, all of which are gluten-free-friendly (along with many other options).
- Oyster Bay Steak and Seafood, open since 1995, clearly marks gluten-free options throughout their menu. Start with the New Jersey crab soup and consider the duck à l’orange for an entrée.
- Bella Vida Café designates special sections of their menu to gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan. This neighborhood café focuses on home cooked food served in a small-town atmosphere.
- The Cricket Club, a beautifully renovated Victorian restaurant that opened in 2022 near the Atlantic Ocean, offers gluten-free standouts like butternut squash bisque, lamb chop appetizers, grilled swordfish, and filet mignon.
- Mad Batter, a longtime Cape May favorite, offers a gluten-free pizza crust option and dishes like chorizo sausage paella.
- Cape May Winery rounds things out with a full menu and flatbreads that can be made with a gluten-free crust on request, a welcome bonus when you are already there for a tasting.
Vegetarian-Friendly Restaurants in Cape May
Vegetarians visiting Cape May will find that most restaurants are genuinely accommodating rather than simply tolerant.
- Iccara Italian Bistro offers a wide range of vegetarian appetizers, salads, and pastas that are crafted with the same care as their meat and seafood dishes.
- Taco Caballito’s brussels sprout taco is a standout as a bright, creative, and satisfying option.
- Louisa’s has found ways to create classic dishes with only vegetables such as their vegetable cakes with spicy catsup.
- The Cricket Club’s Korean tofu lettuce wraps and stuffed pepper with spiced macadamia nuts demonstrate a kitchen willing to think beyond the token vegetarian option.
- Oyster Bay clearly marks vegetarian choices throughout its menu and the truffled beets appetizer is not to be missed.
Vegan-Friendly Restaurants in Cape May
Vegan diners have more options in Cape May than you might expect from a classic Jersey Shore destination.
- Iccara Italian Bistro includes a vegan salad and vegan pasta on the menu.
- Taco Caballito’s brussels sprout taco can be modified to be fully vegan.
- Mad Batter goes further still with an extensive vegan menu spanning breakfast, lunch, and dinner, including vegan white bean ravioli, a vegan “crab” cake sandwich, and pizzas made with vegan cheese. They offer a thoughtful range that makes the restaurant a reliable anchor for plant-based travelers.
- For something lighter and more casual, Aloha Smoothie Company is a gem. Despite the name, it serves a full vegan menu alongside its famous organic smoothies and acai bowls, most of which are made with almond milk and are naturally dairy-free. It is an ideal spot for a breakfast or lunch that leaves you feeling genuinely nourished.
- The standout destination for vegans, however, is Good Earth Organic Eatery, a family-owned restaurant that relocated from Le Marche, Italy, to Cape May in 2012. The restaurant is fully organic, uses only stainless steel cookware, and bakes its own sourdough bread. Vegan options include Penne Pasta Puttanesca, Mushroom Risotto, and Yellow Thai Coconut Curry. Many of their dishes are also free of dairy, eggs, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, and gluten, making it one of the most inclusive kitchens in town.
Cape May has always had a gift for making visitors feel at home, and its restaurant community is no exception. With a little planning, diners with dietary restrictions will find not just workable options but genuinely memorable meals in this Victorian seaside town.
