A visit to Cape May in the off-season reveals a different side of America’s oldest seaside resort showing that there is so much more than just pristine beaches and Victorian charm. For those wondering about things to do in Cape May in the winter, exploring the city’s vibrant culinary scene tops the list. Many of the best restaurants in Cape May, NJ remain open year-round, offering intimate dining experiences without the summer crowds.
The Historic District comes alive with warm, inviting establishments like the Ebbitt Room at the Virginia Hotel, where sophisticated American cuisine meets Victorian elegance. Their winter menu features seasonal ingredients and an extensive wine list, perfect for a romantic evening. Intimate multi-course dinner events are scheduled on various dates in the Richmond Room. Just steps away, the Washington Inn, housed in a restored 1840s plantation home, continues its legacy of fine dining with an impressive wine cellar that has been nationally recognized by Wine Spectator. Start the evening with cocktails in the wine room then continue with a cozy dinner at a fireside table. The Washington Inn is not open year-round but does re-open in early February each year.
For those seeking the best seafood in Cape May, the iconic Lobster House remains a steadfast option throughout the year. Their dining area offers stunning harbor views where everyone can enjoy their famous fresh catches. Visitors can choose from their extensive lunch and dinner menus seven days a week. Fin’s Bar and Grille, another year-round favorite, serves up creative seafood dishes, and live entertainment on the weekends. Head to Fin’s for a fun happy hour Sunday through Friday afternoons.
Bars in Cape May, NJ take on a cozy atmosphere during the winter months. The Ugly Mug, a historic institution along the Washington Street Mall, welcomes visitors with its authentic maritime charm and hearty pub fare. The mugs hanging from the ceiling belong to the Ugly Mug Club in which members drink from their private mug whenever they visit the pub. Delaney’s Irish Pub and Grill offers a warm retreat with traditional Irish dishes and an impressive selection of draft beers, perfect for those chilly winter evenings. Be sure to try some of their fun appetizers such as the Irish Nachos or Reuben Egg Rolls.
The culinary diversity in Cape May extends beyond seafood and pub fare. Bella Vida Café brings Mediterranean flair to breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Their menu is also vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free friendly. George’s Place has been delighting diners with Greek-inspired dishes in a casual setting since 1968. Note that George’s Place is a cash only establishment. Exit Zero Filling Station became a local legend because of their Indian and Thai curries. The dining room is first-come, first-served, but guests can reserve a quirky dining experience in a 1958 Airstream trailer or the cabin of an old Chevy farm truck.
For Italian cuisine enthusiasts, Cape May doesn’t disappoint. Sapore Italiano has some of the lightest homemade gnocchi you have ever tasted. Viggiano’s offers authentic experiences with house-made pasta and traditional recipes that always follow great grandma’s rules. The newer addition, Grana BYOB, has quickly established itself among the best restaurants in Cape May with its contemporary take on Italian classics. Secondo has an impressive menu that features a vibrant mix of Italian and Greek dishes. Check out the cocktail menu for some drink names that will make you chuckle.
Fine dining establishments like Peter Shields Inn maintain their high standards throughout the winter season. Housed in a stunning beachfront mansion, their restaurant boasts five inviting dining rooms with a menu that showcases seasonal ingredients with elegant presentation. Primal takes a different approach, focusing on expertly prepared steaks and fish with a variety of sauce options for each. The modern setting has a contemporary and elegant aura.
Casual dining options abound as well. Lucky Bones keeps their brick ovens burning all winter, serving up some of the area’s best pizzas and casual fare. They are also a great spot for a Cuban Spiced Pork Chop or Baby Back Ribs. Freda’s Café and Deli asks “when is the last time you had a meal that changed your life?” They are a cozy breakfast and lunch spot with creative specials and friendly service. You may feel like you should wear your Sunday best to Panico’s but this restaurant in a renovated church combines casual comfort with quality Italian dishes.
Winter dining in Cape May offers unique advantages. Restaurants often provide more attentive service, and some offer special winter menus or prix fixe options. Many establishments participate in special events, making it an excellent time for food enthusiasts to explore the city’s culinary offerings.
Making reservations is still recommended, especially for fine dining establishments and weekend visits. While some restaurants may adjust their hours during the off-season or take short off-season breaks, most maintain regular dinner service, with some offering lunch or brunch options as well. Remember to check current operating hours before visiting.
The shoulder season and winter months reveal Cape May’s true character as a year-round destination. The reduced crowds allow for a more relaxed dining experience, and the cozy atmospheres of these establishments provide a warm refuge from winter weather. Whether you are seeking romantic fine dining, casual comfort food, or fresh seafood, Cape May’s winter dining scene offers something for every palate.
For visitors and locals alike, exploring Cape May’s restaurants during the off-season provides an opportunity to experience the city’s culinary excellence without the summer rush. The combination of historic settings, creative menus, and warm hospitality makes winter dining in Cape May a memorable experience. From the casual charm of the Ugly Mug to the refined elegance of the Ebbitt Room, each restaurant contributes to Cape May’s reputation as a premier dining destination throughout the year.
